The Azerbaijan State News Agency

Losing Your Religion: Analytic Thinking Can Undermine Belief

Baku, April 28 (AZERTAC). A series of new experiments shows that analytic thinking can override intuitive assumptions, including those that underlie religious belief

People who are intuitive thinkers are more likely to be religious, but getting them to think analytically even in subtle ways decreases the strength of their belief, according to a new study in Science.

The research, conducted by University of British Columbia psychologists Will Gervais and Ara Norenzayan, does not take sides in the debate between religion and atheism, but aims instead to illuminate one of the origins of belief and disbelief. "To understand religion in humans," Gervais says, "you need to accommodate for the fact that there are many millions of believers and nonbelievers."

One of their studies correlated measures of religious belief with people's scores on a popular test of analytic thinking. The test poses three deceptively simple math problems. One asks: "If it takes five machines five minutes to make five widgets, how long would it take 100 machines to make 100 widgets?" The first answer that comes to mind—100 minutes—turns out to be wrong. People who take the time to reason out the correct answer (five minutes) are, by definition, more analytical—and these analytical types tend to score lower on the researchers' tests of religious belief.

But the researchers went beyond this interesting link, running four experiments showing that analytic thinking actually causes disbelief. In one experiment, they randomly assigned participants to either the analytic or control condition. They then showed them photos of either Rodin's The Thinker or, in the control condition, of the ancient Greek sculpture Discobolus, which depicts an athlete poised to throw a discus. (The Thinker was used because it is such an iconic image of deep reflection that, in a separate test with different participants, seeing the statue improved how well subjects reasoned through logical syllogisms.) After seeing the images, participants took a test measuring their belief in God on a scale of 0 to 100. Their scores on the test varied widely, with a standard deviation of about 35 in the control group. But it is the difference in the averages that tells the real story: In the control group, the average score for belief in God was 61.55, or somewhat above the scale's midpoint. On the other hand, for the group who had just seen The Thinker, the resulting average was only 41.42. Such a gap is large enough to indicate a mild believer is responding as a mild nonbeliever—all from being visually reminded of the human capacity to think.

Another experiment used a different method to show a similar effect. It exploited the tendency, previously identified by psychologists, of people to override their intuition when faced with the demands of reading a text in a hard-to-read typeface. Gervais and Norenzayan did this by giving two groups a test of participants' belief in supernatural agents like God and angels, varying only the font in which the test was printed. People who took the belief test in the unclear font (a typewriterlike font set in italics) expressed less belief than those who took it in a more common, easy-to-read typeface. "It's such a subtle manipulation," Norenzayan says. "Yet something that seemingly trivial can lead to a change that people consider important in their religious belief system." On a belief scale of 3 to 21, participants in the analytic condition scored an average of almost two points lower than those in the control group.

Analytic thinking undermines belief because, as cognitive psychologists have shown, it can override intuition. And we know from past research that religious beliefs—such as the idea that objects and events don't simply exist but have a purpose—are rooted in intuition. "Analytic processing inhibits these intuitions, which in turn discourages religious belief," Norenzayan explains.

Harvard University psychologist Joshua Greene, who last year published a paper on the same subject with colleagues Amitai Shenhav and David Rand, praises this work for its rigorous methodology. "Any one of their experiments can be reinterpreted, but when you've got [multiple] different kinds of evidence pointing in the same direction, it's very impressive."

 

Share news on social media

Follow us on social network

Central Bank delegation reviews Swiss National Bank operations

Azerbaijan’s and Poland’s anti-monopoly authorities exchange experience

Chief of General Staff of Azerbaijan Army meets with his Georgian counterpart

President Ilham Aliyev received Vice Prime Minister of Georgia VIDEO

President Ilham Aliyev received delegation led by Foreign Minister of Germany VIDEO

German expert: Azerbaijan has become an important country for EU in economic and geopolitical terms

Alonso to make Dakar Rally return with Aston Martin Dreadnought in 2027

Iraq resumes crude oil exports through old pipeline to Türkiye

1st leader-level Quad meeting in 2 years brings US, Australia, India, Japan together

Another 17 families relocated to Soltanli village receive keys to new homes

Lithuanian Military Academy delegation visits Azerbaijan

Pope calls for ‘less war, less division’ after US midterm elections

UNEC signs memorandums on cooperation with six Georgian Universities

New objectives for Azerbaijani community discussed in Vienna

Cyberattack hits 178 major global brands, exposing visitors to data theft

High-Level D-8 Ministerial Session on Climate Action held as part of COP31

Azerbaijan Minister of Defense receives Georgian delegation

Jeffrey Werbock: My love for Azerbaijan needs no explanation - – INTERVIEW VIDEO ВИДЕО

Sudan: UN report details deadly civilian impact of surge in drone strikes

Japan eyes network to share disaster ınfo across Asia

Baku Engineering University presents international education opportunities in Tbilisi

World Bank Group unveils $17.6B climate, jobs investment package at COP31

Another 48 families relocated to Khojavend receive keys to new homes

Bulgaria’s Deputy PM says creating predictable and stable environment for investors is key commitment of government

Azerbaijan Volleyball Federation official appointed to international competition

Azerbaijan Volleyball Federation official appointed to international competition

UEFA backs French football chief Diallo to challenge Infantino for FIFA presidency

Azerbaijan’s macro-economy 2025-2026 and future prospects

Ambassador: Azerbaijan is a valuable partner in terms of defense and security

Polish media highlights Azerbaijan’s strengthening cooperation with European Union

Military medical personnel of Ministry of Defense visits Poland

How can you recognize a fraud attempt?

AI models abandon climate facts at the first sign of user push-back, UNESCO-UCL report shows

Ambassador: UK welcomes progress towards peace in the South Caucasus

British ambassador: Strategic partnership will further strengthen ties in education and science

Baku Engineering University, Georgia’s prestigious universities sign Memorandums of Understanding

Azerbaijan’s Prosecutor General highlights development of international prosecutorial cooperation in Buenos Aires

Azerbaijan-UK strategic partnership will contribute to economic growth and security, ambassador says

Azerbaijani doctor’s new surgical technique wins top honors at SIU 2026 World Congress

Gritty Spurs deny Jazz for 12th straight win, Lakers keep rolling

Ambassador Duncan Norman: Energy cooperation is a core pillar of our partnership

83 more families relocated to liberated territories under Great Return Program

Azerbaijan and the United Kingdom: from friendship to strategic partnership

® ABB Bank introduces AZAL Miles Business cards, allowing customers to earn miles on business expenses

Researchers in Australia develop bioengineered cornea to address donor shortage

Indonesia re-elected to ITU Council for 2027-2030 term

China's Mengxiang vessel sets world record with new 2,000-meter-class riserless drilling system

OpenAI unveils new tool to detect child sexual abuse material

Tashkent transforms into a golden autumn fairytale

Wirtz screamer leads Germany rout of Netherlands to win Nations League group

Senior military ranks presented to servicemen

Gold and silver prices surge on global markets

7th Pakistan-Italy political consultations focus on trade, security, mobility

Oil prices decline on global markets

Mongolian president announces resignation

Azeri Light sells for $99

First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva shared post on National Revival Day

Post marking National Revival Day shared on President Ilham Aliyev's social media accounts

Baku to host 10th International Banking Forum 2026

Leyla Aliyeva attends opening of Garachukhur Sports Hall

Belgium's top scorer Romelu Lukaku retires from international football

Azerbaijan expresses concern over initiative to name ceremonial hall of Blue Mosque in Iravan after Armenian poet – STATEMENT

Trade between Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan exceeds $306 million in nine months

ECO Council of Ministers highlights Azerbaijan’s efforts towards lasting peace in the region

COP31 President visits Azerbaijani pavilion

UN rights chief urges binding treaty on autonomous weapons before 'too late'

Mukhtar Babayev: Climate finance must be affordable and accessible for countries

Azerbaijani FM discusses regional security and bilateral cooperation with his British counterpart

Caspian Sea environmental challenges highlighted at COP31

Documentary on ecocide committed by Armenia screened at COP31

COP29 President: Protecting forests is key to safeguarding our future

National Paralympic Committee joins international sports seminar in Kazakhstan

Azerbaijan joins Muscat Plan of Action Forum in Oman

New Israeli AI model offers earlier warning of Alzheimer's risk

All 12 crew members rescued after cargo ship capsizes in Bulgarian Black Sea waters

Japan, ADB to support nuclear plant introduction in Asia

Bulgaria becomes full member of International Muaythai Federation, wins hosting rights for Balkan Championship

Turkic World 2026 international dance sport competition held at Sea Breeze

New Israeli algorithm could close dangerous gap in synthetic DNA screening

® Birbank offers military personnel discounts of up to 5% on cash loans

Azerbaijan welcoming ‘set-jetting’ fans of Japan TV drama ‘Vivant’

Main hall of Okinawa’s Shuri castle in Japan unveiled to media

® ABB presents research on human capital in Azerbaijan

® Azercell fosters AI skills development among 100 teachers in Ganja and Khankendi

Azerbaijan, Georgia Railways seek to cut cross-border transit times

Azerbaijan Technical University, China’s University of Shanghai for Science and Technology expands cooperation

Azerbaijan Army serviceman successfully completes NATO Course in Italy

Baku Engineering University team takes first place at NASA Hackathon

Azerbaijan to host 27th WPC Energy Congress in 2030

UN chief calls for 'safe, voluntary' return of Rohingya during 16th ASEAN-UN Summit

ANAMA: 1,459.5 hectares cleared of mines and unexploded ordnance in past week

Azerbaijan joins Web Summit 2026 in Portugal

Phoenix Pavilion set up as part of COP31

COP31 discusses prospects for environmental and climate cooperation among Turkic states

Azerbaijan’s investment opportunities presented in Istanbul

Minister: Number of employment contracts in non-oil and gas private sector more than doubles

Azerbaijan’s Ombudsperson issues statement on munition explosion in Aghstafa

Brazil 1958 World Cup winner and former AC Milan European Cup champion Dino Sani dies at the age of 94

8 killed in mass shooting in South Africa

Kyrgyzstan’s exports grow by 19.3%, imports by 16%